Skip to main content

What does California Assembly Bill 5 (AB5) mean for the Real Estate Industry?


An oft discussed topic for old fogey real estate professionals that the young ‘uns should pay attention to is the special status that real estate agents have as independent contractors. In this country, Real Estate is a protected industry, mainly because it is seen politically as the main step in the ladder to the middle class. This has affected mortgage policy and real estate agents, they have been purposely given generous terms.

The point of bringing these points up is that real estate does not exist in a vacuum, and it cannot exist as it does today without massive government backing, through regulation, taxation and legislation. The recent signing of Assembly Bill 5 (AB5) is a step to close this. Though the purpose of the bill is to target the ‘gig economy’ of Uber, Lyft, Doordash, Postmates and hundreds of others, there was a special exception for certain types of workers, including real estate.

This policy codifies an earlier legal decision from the California Supreme Court (Shorthand Dynamex) that redefines a specific set of criteria for someone to be considered an independent contractor versus an employee, there was a radically re-written set of rules for a company to follow.  Essentially, the bill would require companies to use a legal standard called “the ABC test” when determining employment status:
A): The worker is “free from the control and direction” of the company that hired them while they perform their work.
(B): The worker is performing work that falls “outside the hiring entity’s usual course or type of business.”
(C): The worker has their own independent business or trade beyond the job for which they were hired.

So, who benefits from this? As I learned from my mother, “when you do not understand someone’s motivation, follow the money”. According to the Los Angeles Times, the state “lost” about $7 Billion in payroll taxes in 2017. Is it more likely the state is trying to “help workers” or to fill the general fund? Another cynical outlook is that the state wants to put this into State statute so that the state of California can sue an employer directly, rather than relying on workers themselves to start litigation. It is another continuation of the state believing they know better for adult citizens than they do for themselves.

Real Estate agents are exempt for now, as well as a few other industries, such as law offices, doctor’s offices and accountants. The 40M witnesses in the great state of California are watching, as is the country, on has far these changes will be pushed.

Orange, CA-TRREG DRE#01843673-RP100 DRE#02059058-P:714-831-1800-E:info@theresultsrealestategroup.com-W:www.theresultsrealestategroup.com-Facebook - Twitter - Instagram - LinkedIn

Labels:
Location: Brea, CA, USA

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Fault in our iBuyers(iBrokers)

Today's topic will be about this developing trend of what are called "iBuyers", which are buyers that are more "convenient" to a seller, and who buy houses "as-is" with "all cash". In today's controversial environment of taking a position, this sounds all too familiar.  I would like to bullet point some of the problems of this iBuyer Trend: 1. iBuyers are really iBrokers The "buyers" really are intermediaries for larger venture capital companies, one of these companies, Opendoor, just closed on $300 million more to bring their total funding over $1 billion to buy single family homes for rent and for flip. It is estimated to spend more than $4 billion per year buying homes . Though the terms of the funding are not public, no one hands someone else $1 billion with no strings attached, they have their guidelines and what they can and can not do and are functionally no different than brokers.  2. Therefore, more i
Post a Comment
Read more

Real Estate Investments: Invest Up

I want to speak briefly to the masses today. Normally our audience is the Buyer and Seller, and yet it is easy enough for anyone to become both. It could even happen that you are a Buyer, Seller, and Investor at the same time! How can this be? Me, a normal person can be a Investor? Yes. Even more than that, as soon as you start your journey you start doing something greater than yourself, building generational wealth. Let's start at the very beginning, a very good place to start. This beginning looks like a house purchase. That would be because it is a house purchase. Assuming you are buying this house to rent out, you are now a Landlord and Investor. The first house is going to be the scariest, it gets easier from there. Let's assume you have rented out the house for a couple of years and you are looking to upgrade from a Single Family Residence to a Duplex. You would sell your Single Family Residence and 1031 the proceeds of the sale into the purchase of the duplex. Yo
Post a Comment
Read more

How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Coronavirus

Greetings, Today I wanted to simply jot down some thoughts I had about this novel coronavirus (COVID-19) that the news cycle seems to love to talk about: - Will real estate values be affected? The answer is the same as every real estate question, it depends. I believe luxury will be impacted, I think more modest dwellings will not, and for a very simple reason, there is not more inventory and people have to live somewhere. - Is this our 1987 moment? In 1987 we had Black Monday, the biggest one day stock market drop in history, afterwards, real estate prices went up in a straight line for 18 months. Just like any good investor, when there is a shock to the system, you have to recalibrate, you either go to safety (or even relative safety, like houses versus paper ownership in a company), or you go to what has been undervalued. I suspect there is a good chance this is our 1987 moment for real estate. The 80's are dead, long live the 80's. - The drop in stock price
Post a Comment
Read more